Colour Design Pt. 4: Big Time Interface and Circuit Overhaul August 9, 2013 17:40 16 Comments
In summary, after doing some mixes with the most recent prototype pictured below, I became dissatisfied with the current approach of feeding the dry signal to the colours in parallel and controlling how much of each is mixed in with the dry signal. I found that in almost every application, I was keeping the colours cranked all the way up and turning the dry signal all the way down. In retrospect, this makes sense, as the colours themselves are tuned to impart only subtle distortion, the way a colored preamp or compressor might.
The most recent physical prototype (#4) with JFET, tape, and Cinemag colours installed.[/caption] So I went back to the drawing board, this time with some real mixing experience in hand. One of the first things I knew I wanted to do was simplify the interface. While the idea of having control over the amount of each colour is tempting on paper, in practice I found that I didn't want to be bothered. What I did find myself doing was turning individual colours up and down quickly to hear what the signal sounded like with them bypassed. So I decided to substitute the individual colour volume controls for simple in/out switches. This interface trades a little control for a lot of ease and simplicity. This jives with my original intuitions about Colour: that, like a preamp or tape machine, a harmonics generator is not a piece of gear people want to spend significant time tweaking. Rather, it's something that we should be able to switch into the signal chain with a press of a button, nod with satisfaction, and move on.
A mockup of the current interface with bypass switches instead of individual volume controls for each colour.[/caption] I've also reworked the circuit from the ground up, putting the colours in series rather than parallel and adding a master input drive control. This approach is taken directly from real-word recording practice. When a microphone signal travels through a preamp, and compressor to a tape machine, the coloration from those devices is not applied in parallel. Rather the harmonics generated by the preamp are modified by the compressor, which are then further tempered by the tape. Indeed, part of the art of being a tracking engineer is combining complementary pieces of gear into a signal path. Putting the modules in series makes Colour sound and behave more like a true recording chain.
The new working schematic , with colour modules placed in series with a single input drive control.[/caption] So, that's where are as of now. Circuit boards are already on order for the new design outlined above. If all goes well with this round of prototyping, hopefully I'll have a kit to offer very soon. As always, I welcome and appreciate your thoughts on this project. It's come as far as it has in no small part thanks to your feedback!
Comments
Peterson Goodwyn on December 14, 2014 22:14
Hi Dave,
Thanks a lot for your interest! In fact, Louder Than Liftoff just released a tube Colour last month. Check it out! http://www.diyrecordingequipment.com/products/pentode-colour
Dave Dux on December 14, 2014 12:36
That was a stupid question about stereo/mono versions since that’s what the 500 rack is for, so forget about it. ;) However, it would be nice to have a tube colour module available, too. ;) Cheers!
Dave Dux on December 14, 2014 12:10
I just accidentally found out about this, browsing Youtube after lunch. LOL Excellent idea! I’ve got two questions: will there be stereo/mono models available? just a model with stereo/mono switch and additional inputs/outputs? Are you thinking of making a tube module also? :P :) This makes me very excited. I’d definitely buy one stereo/mono or two mono models if a stereo module is not possible and see how it goes from there… filling a 8ch 500 rack with these would probably be quite awesome. Maybe adding a little summing mixer module to the pack too… ;) I’m so glad I found this website. Cheers!
Jesse on November 12, 2014 18:05
I think simplifying the interface was a good call. There are other tools for surgical manipulations, but something like this should be as simple as gain staging and a button press. I’ve had the pleasure of working with some cool hardware as of late, and I’ve been reminded how certain classic tools are classic because they take 30 seconds to accomplish what might take hours of tweaking otherwise (with hardware or software).
Peterson Goodwyn on November 12, 2014 18:05
Exactly! You put it better than I did in the post. There are tools you want to be surgical, and then there are tools you just want to sit there and do their job without much fiddling.
Brad on November 12, 2014 18:05
What an awesome idea! This will help solidify a lot of guys’ (like myself) decisions about going with transparent pres by letting us add in the flavors that we would have wanted in colored pres later! You’re a genius, Peterson
Peterson Goodwyn on November 12, 2014 18:05
I wish I could accept your praise, Brad, but it was Link who originally floated the idea of “a harmonics (2nd and 3rd) generator” back in May of 2012.
But I’m very glad to hear you can see it fitting into your setup that way. That’s exactly how I envision it and it’s always good to know I’m not talking crazy.
Eric Labrie on November 12, 2014 18:05
Awesome. With the option to make some other color modules, it makes the unit really versatile. Can’t wait to build that great piece of gear. Is making a tube saturation secondary board, or a simulated one, could be possible?
Tony on November 12, 2014 18:05
Really nice progress on a great idea, love the new and simplistic approach. Looks like it will be a very useful tool.
Daniel on November 12, 2014 18:05
Excited to see how it turns out!!!
Kevin Cameron on November 12, 2014 18:05
This is pretty much the only thing that’s keeping me interested in the 500/51x format.
I also love watching the development real-time. It looks like a lot of work, and I’m sure it takes more work than it looks.
Please keep it up! I’ll definitely at least get one.
Peterson Goodwyn on November 12, 2014 18:05
Thanks, Kevin! Things are moving along really quickly now—we’re shooting the video for the Kickstarter campaign next week. Will be taking contributions (pre-orders) very soon.
irfrench on November 12, 2014 18:05
Peterson,
Just wanted to give another thumbs up for this great project! I’ve already come up with a few ideas with one in particular that would work just great in a platform like this.
I can’t wait!
Ian
James on November 12, 2014 18:05
Do you have a eta ??
I’d really like a couple
Erik on November 12, 2014 18:05
Is this project still allive? Any ETA yet? would like to build 2 modules
Peterson Goodwyn on November 12, 2014 18:05
Very much alive, Erik! We’re gathering materials to launch the pre-order ASAP.
Comments are closed for this post.